data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b120a/b120a852ec1e972fe908328479b38ee340c4b8b8" alt="808s and heartbreak pitchfork"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2d707/2d707e5782d0285bb6c7b3112b9b29e210cfddaf" alt="808s and heartbreak pitchfork 808s and heartbreak pitchfork"
West's singing is shaky, of course, which is in part why he leans on the Auto-Tune.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f5e7a/f5e7adcd321eb743cb47cdf2654127e599b72333" alt="808s and heartbreak pitchfork 808s and heartbreak pitchfork"
But it functions here as a democratizer as much as a crutch, because like all Kanye West songs, these are primarily about the experience of Being Kanye West.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/57a45/57a4583ed715da6523d4fd5eba01f397a1814f5b" alt="808s and heartbreak pitchfork 808s and heartbreak pitchfork"
These are expressions of the specific feelings of one guy there is still, to West at least, more emotional nourishment to be wrung from song than speech, which certainly colored his decision here. But filtering these ideas through John Legend or Chris Martin or whomever would essentially kill the whole effect. This isn't new: Kanye West's music is about being a specific celebrity more than anyone's since the solo works of John Lennon. Sure Eminem weaved biography into his songs but he also wore multiple faces and worked in and out of character when it suited him West, on the other hand, is one of the few hip-hop artists without any pseudonyms, let alone characters.Ĭolleagues at Pitchfork have therefore wondered why this wasn't a private record West made for himself, but again nothing he's done is private, and that's in part why he's been so compelling.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b120a/b120a852ec1e972fe908328479b38ee340c4b8b8" alt="808s and heartbreak pitchfork"